"I am a designer. Feel me."
Reviewed by TLo
on
Friday, May 04, 2007
Rating: 5
"I am a designer. Feel me."
Friday, May 04, 2007 by Author
Oh kittens, maybe we've been watching Project Runway for too long, but the "homeward bound" portion of the finale was boring. Gasp! Did we just type that? Could it be that the PRGayBoys are ... over it?
Ha. Not on your life.
Of course we love the show and considering there is no one on the planet who's had more to say about PR than us, we think it's safe to say that we're still firmly in the "obsessed fanboy" camp.
It's just that - remember the other day when we were defending Santino and we said that personality drama was the lifeblood of reality television? Well, that's still true. Now remember when we said one of the few times we get annoyed at reality show drama is when it's too contrived or too producer-created? That's still true too. Holy cow, is it ever.
Of course it's a great idea to travel back to the finalists' homes to get a little backstory and see where they live. We've always loved these episodes. It's just that this season, it seems to us like the producers were working over time to produce tear-jerking backstories where none existed.
Actually, that's not quite true. As these things go, there couldn't possibly be a better story than "My seven sisters and I grew up in a Laotian prison camp and now we live in a McMansion in Houston, Texas!" And maybe that was part of the problem. Chloe had a story that would have been rejected by Lifetime Television for Women as being too unbelievable. The other two designers simply weren't going to live up to that but god bless them (or more likely the producers), they tried.
Let's get this out of the way first: it can be a shitty thing when society considers you an outsider. It's also really difficult to move to a new city with no money and big plans or to be a young gay man in a small town struggling to find your way. We're not denying that these things are hard; but trying to package them as extraordinary stories is a little ridiculous.
With Santino, you got a kindler, gentler version. He was clearly trying to do some damage control after the episodes aired and we have to say, there was definitely something endearing about seeing him so humble. On the other hand, the "walking into the sunset with Tim" sequence was nauseating. You weren't "homeless," you slept on a friend's couch for a couple months until you could get back on your feet. Stop trying to make it sound like you were under a bridge somewhere shooting up with Anthony Kiedis. And what was the point of having Tony Ward there if we can't look at his ass? That's the whole point to Tony Ward.
With Daniel, we just had to laugh. "It was really hard for me to be gay, and here's a bunch of pictures of me modeling different hairstyles to illustrate it. So sad. (pause) Let's go shopping!" Besides, are you really going to enter the fashion world of all places by touting yourself as the gay one? Time to rethink that one, Daniel.
Again, we're not minimizing what in all likelihood were truly painful events in their lives, but when you put them out there as "Here Is My Pain," then it gets a little heavy-handed and eyeroll-inducing. We don't think the designers had it in them to come up with this as a plan. It was more likely the producers pushing them to come up with something they could use. And honeys, when the producers leave their greasy fingerprints all over our tv screens we get cranky. We couldn't even enjoy the required shots of Tim pretending to drive!
[Screencaps: projectrungay.blogspot.com]
Post a Comment
32 comments:
Ouch! You boys a little cranky this morning? The "home visit" episode has always felt like filler. A way to humanize these people we've come to know and love as cartoon characters. Boring? Okay, yeah. But the sneak peak at the collections, seeing where they work and what they deal with (families, boyfriends, cramped working space) AND Tim Gunn in a different context? Not bad. But could probably be handled in a quick video montage at the beginning of Finale Part I.
You know those home episodes....they've always been yawners....Chloe and Uli showdown though.....oooooooooohhhh
Who Had It Tougher??
Uli had it tougher no doubt. She didn't have Barbies, Coke and McDonalds when she grew up. What's a Laotian Familiy prison against that?
And what was the point of having Tony Ward there if we can't look at his ass? That's the whole point to Tony Ward.
Now that's logic for you!
I agree, I hate the Hallmark card epis. It's especially loathsome when some asswipe like Santino or Jeffrey is shown scampering about with adorable tots just to get us to like them. Blech.
I was just thinking you guys are sounding a tiny bit gumpy lately. Between the hating on the reunion episode and now this? Granted, you came up with some brilliant stuff on the reunion episode (Guilty! is still making me smile). If you lovely gentlemen need some time off, take it. Don't burn out!! We all love you and depend on you too much!!
xo
Daniel really got my eyes rolling on this episode. his head was a little too big, and his pockets a little to full of daddy's money.
My favorite part was Chloe trying to hide from Tim the fact that she hadn't really started her collection. She keeps using the word "honestly" in her dialogue with him.
"Honestly, Tim, I haven't done jack shit on this. Let's skip it and go pretend-drive in the Saturn."
— CAAF
I enjoy these episodes far more than the reunion shows, which I'm glad they don't rerun during the marathons. Take it for what it is.
Not every moment has to be overanalyzed.
I like the two-part finale episodes! I think it's great that we get a bit more insight and added dimension with the finalists. Sure, sometimes they seem just a tad contrived, but it's really good to see the designers out of the workroom and in a different setting for a little while. I like the backstories too, since we get to see a little bit what the finalists are about and where they came from.
"Anonymous said...
Daniel really got my eyes rolling on this episode. his head was a little too big, and his pockets a little to full of daddy's money."
I disagree with this assessment of Daniel V. He was confident, yes, as were the other designers, but I do not agree with the statement about his pockets being filled with daddy's money. If that were that case, he wouldn't have needed to be on this show in the first place. (Santino, is that really you by chance?)
JohnP :)
Oh, this is nothing but tough gay uncle love; I don't think you guys are sounding cranky or grumpy at all.
Yeah, I'm not getting a cranky vibe. Just the typical bitchery from our boys.
There was a lot of attempt to redeem Santino. The editors kept shoving it in our faces: Look at what a tough life he's had. Look at how he's tried and failed. That was a bit annoying!
Overall, I thought this episode was a bit boring.
Kristen said...
I was just thinking you guys are sounding a tiny bit grumpy lately.
I disagree. They just had one of the funniest posts ever about Zulema and her model.
Chloe has a very nice and supportive family. That's nice! I felt bad for Santino. It looks like he went through a lot of shit in his life.
" John said...
I like the two-part finale episodes! I think it's great that we get a bit more insight and added dimension with the finalists. Sure, sometimes they seem just a tad contrived, but it's really good to see the designers out of the workroom and in a different setting for a little while. I like the backstories too, since we get to see a little bit what the finalists are about and where they came from.
"Anonymous said...
Daniel really got my eyes rolling on this episode. his head was a little too big, and his pockets a little to full of daddy's money."
I disagree with this assessment of Daniel V. He was confident, yes, as were the other designers, but I do not agree with the statement about his pockets being filled with daddy's money. If that were that case, he wouldn't have needed to be on this show in the first place. (Santino, is that really you by chance?)
JohnP :) "
Did you see the size of his apartment?
Who's Tony Ward? Is he famous?
Tony Ward was Madonna's boytoy in the early 1990s, and he appeared in the "Justify My Love" video.
He was in Bruce LaBruce's "Hustler White," a homo cult classic.
He is also a model.
Here's his site:
http://www.tony-ward.com/
There's a famous shot of Madonna licking his ass for her Sex Book here:
http://www.tony-ward.com/
_private/1992sexbook.htm
Daniel was so full of himself by this point. Ugh.
I love the man, but I have to say that I rolled my eyes when Daniel V said that he was offended because Tim didn't love his collection.
Girrrl, please...
I agree these parts can be a little dull, but I still enjoy seeing some of the designers' backstories. Hey, at least for Season 3, we get turtle poop and Tim Gunn barefoot, and in Season 1, we had Jay's hokey shotgun performance--Season 2 is the weakest of the three. Glad to know Santino is capable of having friends, but it's hard to picture him as anything but a nightmare in the houseguest/moocher role.
"Stop trying to make it sound like you were under a bridge somewhere shooting up with Anthony Kiedis."
so along with your fabulous posts we get a reference to the Red Hot Chili Peppers?
I knew I loved you.
I was curious how Santino, who just a short while ago was "homeless", and is now "broke", can afford to rent a gigantic house in Hollywood with the curved front drive and everything. That place was ten times the size of my house. Miffed, a little.
Whether or not Daniel or any contestant had money from his family, another job or winning the lottery makes no difference. You should not be allowed on this show solely because of your meager bank account. Excluding people because they have money ridiculous. Exclude them for lack of desing talent and the inability to handle the challenges.
i don't care if he has money or not. not the issue. he was on the show because he was talented. he proved that.
like the Boys said, it's the producers who get their greasy fingerprints on the footage and show you the story they want you to see. Daniel probably looked like a flakey rich kid for ratings purposes.
I love the man, but I have to say that I rolled my eyes when Daniel V said that he was offended because Tim didn't love his collection.
Girrrl, please...
Daniel was definitely full of himself by the finale;talented he is, but the ego was ripe for a bit of downsizing
The producers were definitly trying to hard. I think they were disappointed that there wasn't going to be a Wendy Pepper/Kara Saun cagematch so they tried to overwhelm us with sob stories.
Santino's an ass and Daniel is an entitled little princess. Chloe rules!
"Chloe had a story that would have been rejected by Lifetime Television for Women as being too unbelievable."
Ha ha! Yeah, she had a pretty amazing story! The other two, not so much. You're right, not having a home can be traumatic but it's not the same as being homeless. And Daniel's sob story was just pathetic.
I love your commentary on this episode!!
People can go through mental and physical abuse in their childhoods, homelessness, etc without becoming an asshole and tearing others down. It may be cold, but I don't really care what Santino's "story" is, because none of it excuses the way he hurts people with his words and behavior.
I go back and forth about Daniel, sometimes he seems like a sweet kid--other times I sense a subtle air of superiority from him.
Chloe, now there's a story! I wish they got an interview with Mr. or Mrs. Dao to elaborate more on their escape. And for those other schmuck designers to question Chloe's passion? Chloe can wake up, walk into her living room and find her passion. It is in the faces of her parents and their story of struggle.
...off soapbox now....
(sorry, I had finals this week)
Jenn
"Stop trying to make it sound like you were under a bridge somewhere shooting up with Anthony Kiedis."
Oh boys! This made me laugh out loud!
"You weren't "homeless," you slept on a friend's couch for a couple months until you could get back on your feet."
Funny. So, those times when I stayed with friends while in between apartments, I was actually "homeless"? I didn't know that...
Only in America does "not having your own place" = "homeless".
I can't stand it when the producers are so damn obvious about manufacturing drama.
I don't think the Boys are being cranky at all...just their usual pithy selves. :o)
Speaking of homes (or homelessness), Tim Gunn's apartment was featured in one of my darlin' Ed's design magazines this month. I saw it, made a mental note, and then lost the mental PostIt. Did anyone else see the article? I will try to find it again in the stack o' zines at home
Post a Comment